(Undated) -- Andi Dorfman has found her happy ending. She ended her season on "The Bachelorette" accepting the proposal of Josh, the former professional baseball player from her hometown of Atlanta.
The couple was all smiles when they made their debut as an engaged couple on the finale's live aftershow. Andi joked about how she went to such great lengths to find love when the one she chose ended up living just five minutes from her all along. They admitted they'd been using wigs and disguises to sneak to each others' houses since the proposal. Andi appeared happy with her choice, but she also had to face Nick -- the man long considered the front runner for her heart all season long. He arrived at the aftershow heartbroken and looking for answers. Host Chris Harrison revealed that after their breakup, Andi had refused Nick's attempts to reach out twice.
When they finally came face-to-face for the first time, pin drop silence fell over the studio audience. Andi told Nick the truth of the matter was that her feelings for Josh were simply stronger, whether he chose to believe it or not. She seemed uncomfortable when Nick pushed her for more answers. Things between them became tense when Nick said he didn't understand why she "made love" to him if she didn't really love him. Andi called the comment "below the belt," and an emotional Nick had to leave before getting any closure.
Andi and Josh say they've been sneaking around to see each other since the finale.
Nick gets emotional talking to Chris about Andi's choice on the live aftershow.
Andi defends herself against Nick.
Andi says Nick's comment about them making love was below the belt.